Case #1 – Anna’s cold cases
What Anna Found
The woodlot belongs to Floyd Renner, who has six children, a wife who takes in sewing, and no steady work since the canning factory cut back in 1931. That fall, Floyd had been running snares through the Eberly fencerow and his own woodlot. He fed his family on what he caught and sold the rest to a man who drove the rabbits to Indianapolis restaurants on ice. Ward Hollis had warned him twice. That morning, Ward found the snares a third time, pulled them, walked out into the field, and told Ben at breakfast that he’d have to write Floyd up on Monday.
Floyd was in the fencerow watching. When the covey flushed and Ben’s shotgun went off across the field, Floyd fired once with his .22 under the cover of the noise. Ben heard his own two barrels and nothing else. He saw his friend fall and never thought to look anywhere but at the gun in his own hands.
Anna takes the single wound, the eighty-four paces, and the casing to the sheriff. The sheriff asks the doctor to look again. This time the doctor finds a .22 bullet lodged against Ward’s breastbone. Floyd Renner owns a .22 rifle and rolls his own cigarettes. So do half the men in the county, but only one of them had snares in Ward Hollis’s pocket.
Whether it was resolved: Floyd Renner was arrested on November 15th and tried in Muncie in February 1933. He testified that he’d fired at a rabbit and never saw Ward in the corn. The jury was out for less than two hours. It acquitted him. Most of the twelve men on that jury had snared a rabbit in a hard winter themselves, and not one of them had any love for game wardens.
What the trial did do was clear Ben Saylor. The whole county heard it said in court that Ben’s birdshot never touched his friend. Anna saw Ben at the cemetery that spring, putting flowers on Ward’s grave. He was eating again.
What Anna asks readers: Floyd Renner’s children were thin that fall. Everyone in Jeffries could see it. Ward Hollis knew it, too. He had warned Floyd twice instead of writing him up once, and he was going to write him up because he had no other choice. The jury decided that a hungry man with a rifle deserved the benefit of the doubt. Would you have voted with them?