Christmas Angels

A guide for book clubs

About the Book

Christmas Angels by Patra Ann Taylor is a family story of love, loss, and small miracles, set in the small railroad town of Jeffries, Indiana, during the autumn and winter of 1933 — the depths of the Great Depression.

The story is told by Anna Ghere, looking back across a long lifetime to the Christmas she was nine years old. Her family has come through a brutal winter of scarlet fever, and the season opens with a revelation at her little sister Thea’s third birthday supper that strains her parents’ marriage and tests the whole household. Through the weeks leading up to Christmas, a single act of kindness on a stranger’s porch brings a remarkable new friend into Anna’s life, her older sister Gem finds her first love, and the Gheres learn to expect miracles in the darkest of times.

The author dedicates the book to her mother, LouDell Taylor, “who gave me much, including her memories,” and opens with Psalm 91:11: “For he shall give his angels charge over thee, to keep thee in all thy ways.”

Who’s Who

Character	Who they are
Anna Adele Ghere (“Annie”)	The narrator, nine turning ten in 1933. Curious, tender-hearted, and the one who says out loud what the adults won’t.
Gemma Marie (“Gem”)	Anna’s older sister, twelve. Keeps a diary, sews beautifully, stands firmly behind Mother, and falls in love with Fred Moore.
Dorothea (“Thea”)	The baby of the family, three. Lost most of her hearing to scarlet fever.
Mother (Maggie Ghere)	Resourceful, proud, silent in her faith and in her grief. Nursed both girls through scarlet fever alone.
Popo (Augustus “Augie” Ghere)	Anna’s adored father, a traveling feed-and-seed salesman who commands every room he enters — and who leaves when trouble comes.
Gus	The oldest brother; saves coins in a canvas bag for “the big adventure.” The bridge between his feuding parents.
Blinn and Cory	The fifteen-year-old twins, who tend Old Barney the horse and Belva the goat.
Charlie Caldwell	Anna’s cousin, eleven, who boards with the family during the school year. Collects words, reads to Thea, and means to be a journalist like Ernie Pyle.
Laura Beall	The reclusive neighbor the children call “Ghosty.” Albino, nearly blind, and the sole owner and president of the Wanatah Railroad.
Aunt LoRetta (“Aunt Lo”)	Popo’s sister, head librarian, pageant director, rummage-sale strategist, and a pistol by common agreement.
Uncle Karl and Aunt Iris	The relatives across Prairie Creek — “the aristocrats” — stingy with everything but criticism.
Roxy Lockwood	Proprietor of the Blue and White Café, five husbands in, famous for her Coney dogs and her mincemeat pie.
Pauline, Helen, Bernard, Emerson, Marshall, Albright	Anna’s schoolmates — the show-off, the scholar, the Bible-carrier, the bully, the newcomer, and the small boy who sees through everything.
Doc Becker, Old Man Gregory	The family doctor who delivers hard news kindly, and Popo’s friend at the café, also born without pigmentation.

Themes to Explore

One note at a time. Carved above Laura Beall’s door and spoken first by her mother, Elizabeth, this is the book’s working philosophy — for learning music without being able to see it, for building a railroad, for surviving a depression, and for getting through a season of grief.

Kindness as a chain reaction. Anna climbs a stranger’s porch to wipe an egg off a door. That one small act brings her a friend, brings her mother a livelihood, brings Laura Beall out of a decade of seclusion, and ends with a hundred and seven people in a church hall resolving to be the miracle someone else is praying for.

Silence and secrets. Nearly every rupture in the book runs on something unsaid: Thea’s hearing loss, Mother’s own scarlet fever, Popo’s whereabouts, the Thompsons’ marriage. The novel weighs the difference between silence that protects and silence that corrodes — “there’s nothing colder than the ashes of love.”

What “perfect” means. Thea is deaf. Laura is albino and nearly blind. Emerson is written off as a dumb kid. Elizabeth Beall’s answer — love her as she is, because she’s perfect as she is — is the standard every other character is measured against.

Fathers who stay and fathers who leave. Popo is beloved and absent; Edward Beall is frightened and then fiercely present; Mr. Thompson is neither. Gus steps into the gap his father leaves, and Anna inherits that role.

Women who run things. Mother’s cookie business, Aunt Lo’s library and pageant, Roxy’s café, Laura’s railroad, and Sarah Clark Kidder before them all — the book is full of women doing what the town assumes is “man’s work.”

Where are the miracles? Bernard asks the question the whole novel has been circling, and answers it by pointing at what just happened in the room.

Memory as inheritance. An old woman at a window in Jeffries is writing this down so that “generations to come might find hope in the depth of their own despair.” The story was told hundreds of times by three sisters; now only one is left to tell it.

Discussion Questions

Opening — the Prologue and Thea’s birthday (Ch. 1–5)

1. The novel opens with an elderly Anna at her window, writing so that “generations to come might find hope in the depth of their own despair.” How does knowing the ending is survivable change the way you read the hard parts?
2. Anna keeps hearing the line “there’s nothing colder than the ashes of love” and can’t place where it came from. What did you make of it before its source was revealed?
3. Anna blurts out the truth about Thea at the birthday supper. Was she right to? What would it have cost the family if she had kept quiet longer?
4. Mother doesn’t yell — she goes silent and says she has a headache. Anna says she’d have preferred the anger. How does your family handle a blow like this?
5. Popo raises his hand as he walks away up South Street, and Anna can’t tell whether it means stop or goodbye. What do you think he meant?

Beggars’ Night and the stranger on the porch (Ch. 6–12)

6. The children chant at the house of a woman they’ve never met and call her “Ghosty.” What makes a neighbor into a ghost story? Was there such a house where you grew up?
7. Anna goes back alone to clean the egg off the door. Where does that impulse come from — and why does she think first of what Popo would have done?
8. Anna is struck that her black dress is nearly a mirror image of Laura’s, and wonders if she’s looking into “a magical looking glass that was reflecting my future back to me.” What does Anna see in Laura that she wants for herself?
9. Gus takes the broom away and tells Anna, “We don’t hit other people, not even if they deserve it.” He also refuses the Widow Winslow’s nickel. What kind of man is Gus becoming, and why does Anna want to be like him?
10. Anna tells Mother about the coin but leaves out that it’s a half-dollar. What’s the difference between privacy and a secret in this family?

Thanksgiving, birthdays, and Laura’s story (Ch. 13–19)

11. Mother throws Uncle Karl out of Popo’s chair and out of her house — and Anna calls it the most joyful Thanksgiving she’d known. Why is that scene satisfying rather than ugly?
12. Elizabeth Beall answers her husband’s fear with: “we’ll teach her to see with her heart.” Edward’s first reaction was fear, Elizabeth’s was a plan. Were you harder on him than the book is?
13. Mother forgets Anna’s tenth birthday. Laura tells her, “Life is too short to be angry with your mother,” and later makes it a command: “Cherish your mother!” Was that the right thing to say to a hurt ten-year-old?
14. Laura has spent her life practicing for a concert her mother will never hear, and wears black for a loss decades old. Is this devotion, or is it a kind of hiding?
15. Anna asks, “Where are the angels when you need them most?” Laura’s answer — that they’re holding her up — and the ceramic angel from Popo arrive the same night. Did the comfort land for you?
16. Laura makes Anna promise to love both her parents “no matter what.” Is that a fair thing to ask of a child?

Cookies, the pageant, and the finale (Ch. 20–25)

17. Mother accepts an order for eighty-eight dozen cookies in three days, and the whole household is conscripted — even MaMaw, even a second stove on the back porch. What does the work do for Mother that sympathy couldn’t?
18. Aunt Lo maneuvers the hotel manager into freeing Mrs. Thompson for the pageant, and never tells Bernard. Is her meddling a kindness, a performance, or both?
19. Laura tells Anna she’d give the same effort for the King of England as for one child. Where in your own life does that standard feel true — or exhausting?
20. Thea climbs onto the chair Albright left in the “acoustical sweet spot” and lays her ear against the piano. Why does Anna leave her there instead of bringing her back?
21. Bernard throws away Aunt Lo’s written prayer and improvises. He takes the room into real despair — “maybe God is dead” — before bringing it back. Would you have trusted a teenage boy with that?
22. The children vow “never again” about letting Bernard go hungry and alone. Which of the book’s miracles feels largest to you: Thea’s hearing, Laura’s concert, Popo’s return, or Bernard’s parents standing in his circle?

Epilogue and Postscript

23. Popo comes home for Christmas Eve, but Mother never attends the pageant — and Anna tells us plainly that she prayed her mother would love her father again, and “she never did.” How did that ending sit with you?
24. Anna spends her life occupying the common ground between her parents, the place Gus filled before her. Is that a gift or a burden she inherited?
25. Anna is the one who tells Michael to speak, and puts Laura’s hand on his face. What has the nine-year-old from Chapter One become by the last page?
26. Aunt Lo’s last line: “if you don’t believe in miracles, perhaps you’ve forgotten that you are one.” Does the book earn it?

Going Deeper

Questions for groups that want to sit with the book a while longer.

1. On the epigraph. The novel opens with Psalm 91:11 — “For he shall give his angels charge over thee.” By the end, who are the angels of the title? Count them: the ceramic one on Anna’s bureau, the paper wings on the choir robes, the ones Anna says Mother “ordered away” from Thea’s sickbed, the snow angels in the front yard, the stars above Jeffries. What is the book arguing an angel is?
2. On Mother. Anna never once hears Mother speak aloud to God — no thanks, no requests — yet Mother is the one who stays up all night pacing with a dying child and singing All Through the Night. Is the lullaby her prayer? Is hers the most faithful character in the book, or the least?
3. On what the Depression does to a town. Streetlights burn out with no money to replace them. Mr. Bellows is found dead in his shed. A man in Delphi walks into the path of one of Laura’s trains. Fewer porch lights come on each Beggars’ Night. How does the book keep this in view without letting it swallow the story?
4. On an unreliable warmth. This is a memoir written by a woman in her nineties, who tells us her sisters added “adult insights and fresh details” to the story across hundreds of retellings. How much of what we read is 1933, and how much is seventy years of loving revision? Does it matter?
5. On disability, written in 1933 and read now. Doc Becker mentions vacuum tubes making hearing devices smaller, and the nuns at St. Luke’s who will come teach the whole family. Laura has a tutor, a magnifying glass, and Michael as “my eyes and ears.” What does the book get right about how people actually get by — with help, with adaptation, with other people?
6. On the two who leave and come back. Popo always returns but never stays; Laura hadn’t left her house in years until a child knocked. Put them side by side. What does each one need that the other has?
7. Passages worth reading aloud. Elizabeth’s “Let’s build a railroad.” Laura’s “one note at a time.” Mother’s lullaby. Bernard’s “God Almighty is very much alive.” Aunt Lo on love: “Love needs tending.” The Postscript. Which would you want read at your own table?

Bringing It to Your Gathering

On the table. The book is full of food, and nearly all of it is simple enough to make. Maggie’s apple sugar cookies, with apples and honey standing in for rationed sugar. Oatmeal cookies, Laura’s favorite. Sugar-cream pie, the Indiana classic that Uncle Karl grovels for. Roxy’s Coney dogs, if your group likes a party. Fudge and caramels wrapped in wax paper. Horehound drops, strictly as a joke on Aunt Iris. Earl Grey tea, two sugars, poured into the best cups you own.

Set the scene. Carols on in the background — Hark! The Herald Angels Sing, O Come, O Come, Emmanuel, Silent Night. If someone plays, Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata turns the evening into Laura’s concert. Candles, a bowl of popcorn to string, and if you can find it, a Walking Liberty half-dollar to pass around the table.

Things to do together.

• The shoebox. Anna keeps her treasures in one: a lock of baby hair, a bottle cap, delphinium seeds, a slip of paper with a very long word on it. Ask everyone to bring one small object they’ve kept for no practical reason, and say why.
• One note at a time. Go around the table: name one thing you’re facing that can only be done one note at a time.
• Be the miracle. Bernard’s charge to the hall was to be the miracle somebody else is praying for. Decide on one small, specific thing your group will do before the next meeting — the modern equivalent of carrying the Widow Winslow’s groceries and refusing the nickel.
• Snow angels, optional. Weather permitting. Charlie made a perfect one.
• The word game. Charlie’s dictionary word was antidisestablishmentarianism. Have everyone bring the longest or strangest word they know and make the others guess what it means.

A note for hosts. The book moves from a hard, silent autumn to a full church hall on Christmas Eve, and a group often moves with it. If the conversation gets quiet around Thea, or around a parent who left, that’s the book working. Let it sit, then read something aloud.

You’ll find the link to your free Book Club Guide below.

Download your free Book Club Guide here.